Buying vs Leasing a Car: Which Option Is Cheaper? A Comprehensive Comparison

Which Option is More Affordable? Buying vs. Leasing a Car:


When it comes to purchasing a car, making the right decision can have a significant impact on your finances. Two popular options are buying a car outright and leasing a car. Each option has its advantages and considerations, and in this article, we will explore these choices in detail. We will compare the costs and financial implications of buying, leasing, and alternative financing methods, such as Higher Purchase and Personal Contract Purchase (PCP). By understanding the pros and cons of each approach, you can make an informed decision that suits your needs and budget.

The Four Ways to Finance a Car Purchase


There are four primary methods for financing a car purchase, each with its own distinct features. These methods are buying outright, finance, personal contract purchase, and personal contract hire. When you buy a car outright, you become the full owner, and in the long run, it tends to be the cheaper option. On the other hand, leasing allows for lower monthly payments and the luxury of driving a brand-new car.


1. Personal Loan: With a personal loan, you pay a deposit and borrow the remaining amount at a set interest rate for an agreed period.


2. Hire Purchase: This method involves making monthly repayments and eventually owning the car at the end of the payment term.


3. Leasing: By choosing to lease a car, you make monthly payments to use the vehicle for a specific period and return it at the end of the contract.


4. Personal Contract Purchase (PCP): PCP involves setting a term for the agreement, paying a deposit, and making monthly payments based on the loan amount and the estimated value of the car at the end of the agreement.


Cost Analysis: Higher Purchase Financing Option


Let’s take a closer look at the Higher Purchase financing option as an example. Suppose the cost of the car is £34,000, with a deposit and an interest rate of less than 11 percent. For a three-year term, the monthly payments would amount to £810. At the end of the contract, you would have full ownership of the car. However, if you were to sell the car, the estimated price would be around £16,000.


Options for Owning a Car for Three Years


It’s worth considering the various options for owning a car over a three-year period. Selling a car after three years may not yield profitable results due to the current bubble in secondhand car prices. Alternatively, leasing a car with a deposit and monthly payments would cost approximately £17,000 for three years, without any interest. PCP is a popular option, but it often receives heavy promotion from dealerships.


Total Cost Considerations: PCP


Despite its popularity, PCP may not always be the best option in terms of total cost. If you were to return the car at the end of the contract, leasing would save you £4,000 compared to PCP. Car dealerships often push for PCP since it is more profitable for them. 

However, the PCP option may still be the best choice for some individuals, considering specific factors. Conducting a comprehensive analysis of the total cost, including maintenance, insurance, and potential resale value, is crucial. The higher purchase option may save money if you plan to keep the car at the end of the contract. Additionally, buying a car outright and selling it in the secondhand market could be the most cost-effective approach. However, it is essential to factor in the opportunity cost of investment.


Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Buying and Leasing a Car


Several factors should be taken into account when deciding between buying and leasing a car. Buying a car provides full ownership and the ability to customize it to your liking. However, it also entails higher maintenance costs over time. Leasing, on the other hand, offers lower monthly payments and the opportunity to trade in for a newer car regularly. However, it comes with restrictions on customization and mileage.


Buying a Pre-Owned Car: A Viable Alternative


Another option worth considering is purchasing a pre-owned car instead of buying a new one. It is advisable to calculate the cost per mile if you anticipate going over the mileage restrictions. Buying a pre-owned car that is two to three years old and has already depreciated can often be the most cost-effective choice.



When it comes to choosing between buying and leasing a car, several considerations must be weighed. While buying outright provides long-term ownership benefits, leasing offers lower monthly payments and the opportunity to drive a new car regularly. Exploring financing options like Higher Purchase and PCP can further help in finding the best fit for your needs. By analyzing the costs, financial implications, and individual preferences, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your budget and lifestyle.


5 Tips for Smart Car Buying: Your Ultimate Guide.



You have to wait 20 seconds.

Leave a Comment